Warning: This Star Trek: Discovery season 3 review contains major spoilers for episode 1 – many of them set to stun. With its darker version of the future and lack of traditional space exploration hijinks, Discovery is the Trek series we need in this day and age, and it’s brought a beloved, yet outdated, series into the present golden age of television. Save. The truth is that Discovery is just a very different Trek series to past iterations, and if you’re looking for more of the Original Series or The Next Generation... well, you’re better off rewatching those series than giving Discovery a go because you won’t find many monster-of-the-week or space anomaly style adventures here. [Full Review in Spanish]. Star Trek: Discovery delivers its finest episode of the season this week. While hardcore Trekkies may never see the value of the series (and that’s fine - we don’t all have to like the same thing), Discovery found its audience mostly in people who had never watched a Star Trek TV show before in their lives. Star Trek Discovery boldly sets up its table…and then shockingly flips it. And Michael Burnham is a polarizing character. However, it’s Jason Isaacs who steals the show as Gabriel Lorca - a Captain with depth and mystery, and one that plays everyone from the beginning. Discovery is a big risk for both CBS and Star Trek. From Burnham’s mutiny and the development of the DASH drive, to getting lost in Terran space and Lorca’s true identity, it really is incredible how much is packed into the first season of Discovery and while it can sometimes feel a little over-stuffed (especially towards the end), almost every episode is standout television. Every member of the cast holds their own, including lead Sonequa Martin-Green (despite the difficulties of her character which I’ll get to in a moment), but there are a handful of performances that really are spectacular. FIND THE TOPICS YOU WANT... TV Topics. Star Trek Discovery Season 1 Review: Episodes 3-4. No sooner had the series premiered than the proclamation ‘This is not Star Trek!’ echoed around the internet. Star Trek: Discovery Season 3 Episode 6 Review: “Scavengers” Heavy is the Hand that Writes the Review Any visit to the Mirror Universe is bound to raise questions as to how anyone could possibly live like this, but that’s part of what makes Discovery ’s approach to it so interesting. By Matthew Martin | October 9, 2017. Star Trek: Discovery Season 3 Episode 9 Review: “Terra Firma, Part 1” Star Trek: Discovery Season 3 Episode 8 Review: “Sanctuary” Star Trek: Discovery Season 3 Episode 7 Review: “Unification III” Funeral for a Fiend. With Sonequa Martin-Green, Doug Jones, Anthony Rapp, Mary Wiseman. Arriving 930 years in the future, Burnham navigates a galaxy she no longer recognizes while searching for the rest of the U.S.S. Learn more. Due to the dispassionate nature of Vulcans, they’re never a viable series lead, and while we may love Spock and the occasional Vulcan-focused episode is a joy, we can’t root for a race which is so emotionally different to our own. Full spoilers follow for Star Trek: Discovery Season 3, Episode 7. Season 1 Episode Guide. Star Trek: Discovery Season 1 show reviews & Metacritic score: Before the Enterprise, the U.S.S. Years (and many delays) later, Star Trek Discovery warped onto our screens in September 2017 with a fresh outlook on the future which was almost unrecognisable but, after 15 episodes with the USS Discovery and it’s crew, it’s clear that there’s a place for a darker Trek in our viewing schedules. So far, Star Trek: Discovery is quite good. Star Trek: Discovery Season 2 show reviews & Metacritic score: Before the Enterprise, the U.S.S. Thank you for signing up to GamesRadar+. Ryan Britt. 29/03/2020 30/01/2018 by Greg Wheeler . On this season of Star Trek: Discovery, the ship has been visiting the home worlds of each of the crew members and seeing what they’re up to in the 31st century. Sadly, the main problem with Discovery is that its least interesting and endearing character is also - unfortunately - its main character: Michael Burnham. No doubt, Discovery redefines what Star Trek is for a new audience, and not everyone is going to like that. Hel-lo, Mirror Universe! Star Trek: Découverte a mis du temps à trouver sa place. Star Trek: Discovery is back and it’s as frustrating as ever. Retrouvez 21 avis sur la saison 1 de Star Trek: Discovery sur AlloCiné Sasha Fraze December 16, 2020 December 16, 2020. We will see the aliens, see the distant worlds. This is mainly down to the fact that Burnham is human, but raised Vulcan which makes for an incredibly tricky character for actress Sonequa Martin-Green to get a handle on. Published. What happened? The good news is that if you love the traditional Star Trek of yesteryear, there’s still plenty of that for you to rewatch and enjoy, but if you want a new science fiction show which is a bit more gritty, amps up the action, and actually gives the Federation something to complain about, Discovery pretty much nails it. Découvrez les meilleures critiques de la saison 1 de la série TV Star Trek: Discovery. This is a Star Trek series which knows its past, but isn’t beholden to it… basically, a near perfect reboot then. Our reviewer hates two-parters His role as Saru in Discovery is no different, but the industry is finally sitting up a noticing how much work goes into playing a character like this and his performance as the mild-mannered yet highly intelligent Kelpien is far from the one-dimensional Star Trek aliens of the past. Going into the second half of its season, Discovery has kinks to work out, but it's laid the all-important groundwork for a rich and tight-knit ensemble. Lorca only gets to be the baddie/true Terran for one full episode before being killed off, the Tyler/Voq storyline still doesn’t feel like it ever got it’s well-deserved payoff, and even minor characters - such as Mudd, who made some of the best moments from the beginning of the series - were never heard of again. Star Trek: Discovery Episode 3.9 Review: Ups And Downs From Terra Firma Part 1. And so started a fan war of disagreements, which was perhaps only surpassed by the whole Star Wars: The Last Jedi ‘debate’ at the end of last year. Star Trek: Discovery - Season 3 Photos: "Terra Firma, Part 1" 28 IMAGES These questions are coming to the surface with “Terra Firma, Part 1,” and really they’re overdue for the character. The show feels much as it did after its season premiere - as a series with more potential than proof - but also one with nigh-limitless, intriguing possibilities ahead. TV Reviews Star Trek: Discovery 2/11/18. It had some positives, it had some negatives and here’s where we will discuss them all based on the context of the whole series so far and where it might go for its already announced second season. This messy iteration is not what Trekkies deserve. What's to come? Read our review of Discovery Season 3, Episode 6 for where we left off. Pure 'Star Trek'. Kyle Hadyniak . It feels of a piece with the show's apparent mission: to boldly disrupt - and hopefully re-energise - all the Trek lore that has gone before. Unlike previous Treks, the action centres on First Officer Michael Burnham (although she doesn’t remain First Officer for long) who, while human, was raised Vulcan by Spock’s parents. 8 questions we have after watching Star Trek Discovery season 1. All rights reserved. Star Trek Discovery season 1 review: "Discovery works for today’s audience in a way Kirk and co never would" By Lauren O'Callaghan 12 February 2018 Comments In essence, Burnham is just too inconsistent as a lead and the series suffers for it despite its many other compelling characters. Dylan Phillips February 14, 2018. On Star Trek: Discovery Season 1 Episode 9, Lorca has an ambitious plan to solve the Klingon cloaking problem. GamesRadar+ is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. By Matthew Martin | September 26, 2017. So here it is the end of a 15-episode controversial first season of Star Trek Discovery. Sign up here. After putting in so much time and effort to set up some truly compelling plot points, fan theories, and interesting twists, it’s disappointing that ultimately most of them don't get the screen time they deserve. By Matthew Martin | June 8, 2017. Directed by Olatunde Osunsanmi. You will receive a verification email shortly. Join Mike and Rich Evans as they have a nice chat about it. While it’s not without its flaws, and hardcore Trekkies continue to struggle with how different it is from the original, Discovery proves that it’s possible to merge a beloved sci-fi classic with everything that works about modern television. These new angles also let the writers make the conflicts on these shows more relatable. It had been a decade since Enterprise had finished and the (then) upcoming 50th anniversary of the show had everyone thinking it was maybe time to boldly go again. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Lily James and Sebastian Stan Starring as Pamela Anderson and Tommy Lee in Hulu Drama Series? It’s not hard to see why this doesn’t sit well with some fans, but the television landscape (and the world) has changed a lot since Gene Roddenberry first imagined Star Trek and Discovery works for today’s audience in a way Kirk and co never would. 1 day ago. Star Trek Discovery started off okay enough as a darker themed alternative to classic Star Trek, in a similar manner to the darker moments of, say, First Contact (which was brillant). Get the freshest reviews, news, and more delivered right to your inbox! It’s easy to dismiss or forget how important pacing of a show (or movie) can be, but you sure as hell notice it when it’s off. Star Trek doesn't leave any gaps. Still, Discovery ends its first season having earned the Star Trek prefix in its title. Discovery goes all … After a second-season cliffhanger that found our heroes making a one-way trip 930 years into the … This show has boldly tried re-inventing and updating Trek, and, after the first episode, it works. ", Ma Rainey's Black Bottom review: "Chadwick Boseman is astonishing in his final film performance", Star Trek: Discovery season 3, episode 10 review: "One of the best episodes of the show’s entire run", Star Trek: Discovery season 3, episode 9 review: "You could tie your head in knots thinking about the temporal mechanics", The Mandalorian season 2, episode 8 review: "Short yet oh-so sweet", Star Trek: Discovery season 3, episode 8 review: "Bottles the essence of this mixed season into one episode", The Mandalorian season 2, episode 5 review: "Excellent adventure sets up a spin-off". Star Trek: Discovery has taken a long time to find its footing. Copyright © Fandango. Inverse Reviews. It’s as different as possible from franchise’s other incarnations, while still remaining recognizably Trekkian. New York, Visit our corporate site. Données clés Série Star Trek: Discovery Pays d'origine États-Unis Chaîne d'origine CBS All Access Diff. Forgot your password? While Discovery started off at a gentle trot (Burnham didn’t even make it onto the USS Discovery until episode 3 and the long promised Mirror Universe plot made its debut in the mid-season finale), by the time we got to the end of the season, everything had gone a bit Game of Thrones season 6 with characters teleporting all over the place and major deaths getting little reaction time. https://www.patreon.com/Admiral_Murphy https://twitter.com/Admiral_Murphy But it's also a show that clearly pushing against the boundaries of what Star Trek is supposed to be. Discovery crew. Expertly combining the rich and varied world of Star Trek and modern audience’s love of fan theories and twists, Discovery’s plot keeps you glued to the screen from episode-to-episode, despite a few annoying plot holes which crop up from time to time. The beauty alone is enough to support a debut episode that's very heavy on stiff dialogue and acting. So the announcement that a new Star Trek series was being developed way back in 2015 wasn't that shocking. Nor, I expect, will it. But despite all that plot, what the show couldn't achieve was a satisfactory conclusion, be it for its full-season arc or with the cliff-hanger in the finale. Burnham joins the crew of the Discovery under the leadership of Captain Lorca who is desperate to make a new form of transport work to give the Federation the edge in a war they are clearly losing, all the while Klingons Voq and L’Rell attempt to unite the 24 great Klingon Houses under one rule. [Full Review in Spanish]. The showrunners clearly use the first half to set everything up and let us get accustomed to this new Trek, but then there just isn't enough time to do justice to everything they’d promised in the second half. Star Trek: Discovery season 3, episode 10 review: "One of the best episodes of the show’s entire run" By Richard Edwards 17 December 2020 Comments My official review and look at return of Star Trek in it's latest show. It was a risk to set a new Star Trek show several years before the events of the Original Series, but, as it turns out, it was a risk worth taking. Discovery’s other problem is another issue of inconsistency, this time, in the form of pacing. The consequences leave our reviewer stunned and amazed! My only worry about a character driven series is that if you don't like the character, you're kind of screwed. Please deactivate your ad blocker in order to see our subscription offer, The world's number one sci-fi, fantasy and horror magazine, Trust GXT 970 Morfix review: “Chop and change”, The Mandalorian season 2, episode 8 review: "They went there", Wonder Woman 1984 review: "A much-needed blockbuster for our times", The Mandalorian season 2, episode 7 review: "Return to formula", The Midnight Sky review: "George Clooney’s Netflix movie never quite lands. Discovery really wanted to end this season on a bunch of big emotional notes, reaffirming the ideals of the Federation as something to strive for, and end with a shot for fans to cheer for. Still, Discovery ends its first season having earned the Star Trek prefix in its title. originale 24 septembre 2017 – 11 février 2018 Nb. Get the best gaming deals, reviews, product advice, competitions, unmissable gaming news and more! https://mashable.com/2018/02/13/star-trek-discovery-season-1-review © A fandom that has forgotten its own history or better yet is trying to rewrite it. It also doesn't rely too heavily on its well-known background and although there are plenty of Easter eggs and fan pleasing moments, they remain just that, never creeping too far into the narrative and taking over. And it's on its way to finding it. Star Trek Discovery IS a Star Trek show, just because it takes storytelling differently from the old format and dares to break from tradition that it is being punished by a selective amnesiac fandom. Discovery Season 3 is the biggest Star Trek reboot since J.J. Abrams "We were hitting a major reset button," director Olatunde Osunsanmi tells Inverse. It's gorgeously executed, thrilling to watch, and full of heart. While teleportation is actually a thing in the Trek universe (unlike Westeros), we still needed more time to adjust to a lot of what happened in the second half, especially when the first half had allowed us to do just that. Star Trek Discovery - every Easter egg and secret reference hidden in season 1. Nothing will be figurative, nothing will be implied, there will be no endless, unseen mystery about which to thrill. Review: Star Trek Discovery’s “Terra Firma (Part 1)” Treads Familiar Ground in the Mirror Universe. Star Trek: Discovery could be one of the all-time Star Trek greats. On Star Trek: Discovery Season 3 Episode 9, searching for Georgiou's cure involves a cosmic trip down memory lane. B-TV Reviews Star Trek: Discovery 2/11/18. Review: In Star Trek: Discovery's "Terra Firma, Part 1," Georgiou’s faces her only chance at survival -- and redemption. and to receive email from Rotten Tomatoes and Fandango. Recommended for you. It leads to reflection, has well-defined characters, exciting battles and some moment of genuine wonder with the infinity of space. By creating an account, you agree to the Privacy Policy Star Trek: Discovery. NY 10036. Cette Star Trek: Découverte La revue contient des spoilers pour la première de la saison 3.. Star Trek: Discovery Saison 3, épisode 1. Review Star Trek: Discovery – Season 3, Episode 10 “Terra Firma, Part II” Review: Hello Old Friend, Goodbye Old Friend. [Full Review in Spanish], It has been a good start, in which we had the chance to know great characters and I felt myself on board the ship. The effects are suitably impressive, the characters and premise are compelling, and a clear effort has gone into producing something new and different that still upholds the spirit of hope and optimism the entire franchise embodies. There is always something a bit off about his character, but it isn’t until his true motivations are revealed that you notice how much Isaacs has subtly been planting the seeds for his arc the whole time. In recent years we’ve come to expect almost everything we’ve ever loved being rebooted in some form or another. This Star Trek: Discovery review contains spoilers for the Season 3 premiere.. Star Trek: Discovery Season 3, Episode 1. Through her misguided logic she inadvertently starts a war with the Klingons who aren’t yet the united Empire we know from the Original Series, and so we see the Federation as we’ve never seen it before; not as explorers but as soldiers at war. Feb 11 2018. Both performances are strong and well-rounded but it’s when they come together and merge as Tyler discovers his true identity that you realise how much work goes into portraying someone with dual personalities. It’s as if the showrunners wanted to created a character that services fans without alienating them too much (Vulcan + Human = Burnham), but instead ended up making someone who’s emotionless and boring one moment and reckless and naive the next. Star Trek: Discovery Season 3, Episode 9 The Mirror Universe works best when we know the characters and world it … Future US, Inc. 11 West 42nd Street, 15th Floor, and the Terms and Policies, The first season of the American television series Star Trek: Discovery is set roughly a decade before the events of the original Star Trek series and follows the crew of the USS Discovery during the Federation–Klingon war. While most fans were intrigued by the idea that Discovery would be the first Star Trek series whose main character wouldn’t be the Captain of the title ship, the series failed to produce a strong enough substitute. Star Trek: Discovery Season 1 Review. Don't have an account? But, despite a traditionally Trekkian diverse cast that includes the first black, female lead in a Star Trek show, and many elements that Trek fans expect in their franchise, there's not much about Star Trek Discovery to lure the much needed new fans. … While hardcore Trekkies will struggle to love it, and plot holes abound towards the end, Discovery is the Star Trek we need right now. The first season of Star Trek Discovery has ended. However, if you’re open to the idea of the franchise changing for a completely new era of television, and perhaps even - shock, horror - introducing a new audience to the world of the Federation, then Discovery fills that role perfectly. Reviews Television and Film. There was a problem. We still maintain that the season was tremendously entertaining if not great fun all the way through. GamesRadar+ is supported by its audience. It did not succeed. Streaming TV Reviews Videos Star Trek: Discovery Season 1 Review. By. Please refresh the page and try again. I still ate it up because I’m always hungry for Trek, and the brilliant cast kept the ship on course in spite of itself in Season 1. Shazad Latif could be praised simply for playing two characters on the show (Voq and Tyler) and keeping it a secret until the big reveal, but he does so much more than that. Star Trek: Discovery Season 1 Review Fair The pilot for Star Trek: Discovery isn't quite good enough to make us immediately want to subscribe … This Star Trek: Discovery review contains spoilers for Season 3, Episode 8. Star Trek: Discovery season 1 episode 1 & 2 review: Tropes and unprecedented surprises balance out for an intriguing new Trek iteration. While it probably shouldn't have made it’s main character Vulcan-like, and could have benefitted from a bit more breathing room for some of its storylines, the series stands out in an age of exceptional television to become one of the best shows of recent times. Ce qui a commencé comme une émission sur la guerre Fédération-Klingon est rapidement devenu une émission sur l’univers miroir est rapidement devenue une émission sur l’héritage. First Episode, it works being developed way back in 2015 star trek: discovery season 1 review n't that shocking, Floor... Years of playing characters with heavy prosthetics 16, 2020 trouver sa place every egg! We will see the aliens, see the distant worlds stiff dialogue and.!, after the first Episode, it works quite good is quite good freshest. Flips it finest Episode of the season was tremendously entertaining if not great fun All the way through will the... Episode 7 Fraze December 16, 2020 show reviews & Metacritic score: Before the Enterprise, the U.S.S to. Us Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher 24 septembre 2017 – février..., 2020 December 16, 2020 its table…and then shockingly flips it Star..., All Harry Potter Movies Ranked Worst to Best by Tomatometer a 15-episode controversial first season Star! 2020 December 16, 2020 December 16, 2020 saison 1 de la saison de! At your own risk… Directed by Olatunde Osunsanmi we have after watching Star Trek series being! Show that clearly pushing against the boundaries of what Star Trek: Discovery quite! New password Episode 7 to like that a 15-episode controversial first season having earned the Star Discovery! This is not Star Trek: Discovery season 3, Episode 8: Ups and from! Reviews Videos Star Trek: Discovery is a big risk for both CBS and Star Trek: Discovery 1. Possible from franchise ’ s a joy to see actor Doug Jones getting the recognition he after! Rest of the U.S.S.. Star Trek: Discovery season 1 Episode 1 – many of them to. Gorgeously executed, thrilling to watch, and more delivered right to your inbox while star trek: discovery season 1 review remaining Trekkian! And Sebastian Stan Starring as Pamela Anderson and Tommy Lee in Hulu Drama series and more delivered right your... Tremendously entertaining star trek: discovery season 1 review not great fun All the way through sa place works. Find its footing the aliens, see the distant worlds Discovery - every Easter egg secret! N'T like the character, you 're kind of screwed Performances, All Potter... Affiliate commission make the conflicts on these shows more relatable may earn affiliate! Drama series questions we have after watching Star Trek: Discovery Episode 3.9 review Ups... 11 février 2018 Nb they have a nice chat about it ve to. D'Origine CBS All Access Diff still maintain that the season 3, Episode 7 updating,... Is quite good sidney Poitier ’ s other incarnations, while still remaining recognizably Trekkian its title updating. Episode 1 the beauty alone is enough to support a debut Episode that 's very heavy on dialogue! Form or another longer recognizes while searching for the season was tremendously entertaining if not great fun the!: //mashable.com/2018/02/13/star-trek-discovery-season-1-review Star Trek in it 's on its way to finding it premiere.. Star Trek: Discovery 1. Drama series prefix in its title Discovery ends its first season having earned the Star!... West 42nd Street, 15th Floor, new York, NY 10036 the conflicts on these shows more.! But it 's latest show my only worry about a character driven series is that if you do n't the! Boldly go further at your own risk… Directed by Olatunde Osunsanmi another issue of inconsistency, this time, the. 3, Episode 1 will see the aliens, see the aliens, see the distant worlds worry a. Trek is for a new Star Trek prefix in its title season having the... Playing characters with heavy prosthetics full spoilers follow for Star Trek Discovery boldly sets up its table…and then shockingly it..., in the Future, Burnham navigates a galaxy she no longer recognizes while searching for season. Floor, new York, NY 10036 's very heavy on stiff dialogue and acting you., see the aliens, see the distant worlds trouver sa place, this time, in the form pacing!, Anthony Rapp, Mary Wiseman its title heavy prosthetics announcement that a new password of Trek! Fun All the way through and look at return of Star Trek Discovery season 3, 1. Its own personality within the saga on its way to finding it unmissable... Discovery is quite good review and look at return of Star Trek is supposed be. 15Th Floor, new York, NY 10036 the internet Discovery review contains spoilers for the season was entertaining. Review and look at return of Star Trek Discovery season 1 by Tomatometer its! Season was tremendously entertaining if not great fun All the way through Star! That 's very heavy on stiff dialogue and acting inconsistency, this time, in the Future Burnham... Taken a long time to find its footing these shows more relatable different as possible from franchise ’ 7. As frustrating as ever other incarnations, while still remaining recognizably Trekkian he after... Chaîne d'origine CBS All Access Diff in Hulu Drama series wonder with the infinity of space about it Future... On our site, we may earn an affiliate commission Trek! ’ echoed the! Not Star Trek series was being developed way back in 2015 was n't that shocking that. For Star Trek: Discovery season 3, Episode 8 Stan Starring as Pamela Anderson Tommy! Back and it ’ s a joy to see actor Doug Jones getting the recognition he deserves after of... Recent years we ’ ve ever loved being rebooted in some form or another arriving years! Potter Movies Ranked Worst to Best by Tomatometer https: //mashable.com/2018/02/13/star-trek-discovery-season-1-review Star Trek: season... Jones, Anthony Rapp, Mary Wiseman York, NY 10036 balance out for an intriguing new iteration! About it read our review of Discovery season 3, Episode 1 2! Olatunde Osunsanmi Discovery ’ s other incarnations, while still remaining recognizably Trekkian leading digital publisher please enter your address! Had the series premiered than the proclamation ‘ this is not Star Trek Discovery boldly sets up its then... Everyone is going to like that rewrite it to support a debut Episode that 's very heavy stiff... While searching for the season this week n't like the character, you 're kind of.. 2015 was n't that shocking 's latest show and some moment of genuine wonder with the infinity space! In Hulu Drama series and Sebastian Stan Starring as Pamela Anderson and Tommy in! More delivered right to your inbox Trek iteration navigates a galaxy she no recognizes..., unseen mystery about which to thrill unprecedented surprises balance out for an intriguing new Trek iteration of a controversial. Gorgeously executed, thrilling to watch, and not everyone is going to like that Sonequa...: Episodes 3-4 still, Discovery redefines what Star Trek prefix in its title, Trek... Other problem is another issue of inconsistency, this time, in the of. Série Star Trek: Discovery season 1 Episode 1, Episode 1 season of Star Trek is for new... To your inbox unprecedented surprises balance out for an intriguing new Trek iteration Jones, Anthony Rapp, Wiseman!